So, your product’s got a leaky bucket problem…

How to design a cancellation flow that respects your user while minimizing churn (yes, it’s possible!)

Let’s get this out of the way: the goal of this post is to help you mitigate churn (account cancellations) by implementing user-centric yet business-driven design.

Churn is something all subscription, advertising, transactional, or commission-based businesses deal with. By truly understanding how to work with churn, you can display how design can play a pivotal role in a business’ success.

A considered exit ramp could help reduce churn by up to 10% and save an at-scale company millions annually.

To be clear, the ultimate way to reduce churn is to consistently add value to your product whether that be with new features, personalization, delight, or any other addition to your experience that makes your users feel like paying for a subscription is worthwhile.

Spotify consistently adds value by releasing fun user-centric features
Spotify consistently adds value by releasing fun user-centric features

Great examples of this are Spotify’s Time Capsule, Wealthsimple’s Socially Responsible Investing, or Airbnb’s Experiences. Regardless of industry, these companies have done an excellent job showing their users the value of the product, and continuing to deliver on that.

Wealthsimple has an SRI portfolio option, something many of their competitors don’t offer yet.
Wealthsimple has an SRI portfolio option, something many of their competitors don’t offer yet.

Consistently adding value keeps competition at bay. They’ll never catch up. The goal is to have users accept your product as part of their daily life, where they can’t imagine life without it.

Airbnb reaches beyond home-sharing with experiences
Airbnb reaches beyond home-sharing with experiences

Why do people unsubscribe?

Many reasons. It’s possible you’re not delivering anything useful anymore, maybe users are unsatisfied, or find the product too expensive. But it’s not always a goodbye forever, and that’s why a well-designed cancellation flow is so important. A considered exit ramp could help reduce churn by up to 10% and save an at-scale company millions annually. 💸

Here are a few simple steps you can take to achieve this:

Get to know churn intimately

Think about why you’ve unsubscribed from products. Talk to your friends, family, and teammates about why they’ve opted out of paid services and try to really understand the motivations and early signs of potential cancellation.

Talk to users who have churned

Don’t be shy — say hello! Coordinate interviews with a small segment of users who have unsubscribed and ask them questions. Find out why they cancelled, where they believed it was lacking, etc. This will help guide you toward what to surface as part of your cancellation flow.

Involve your Customer Support team

Customer Support teams often feel left out of product decisions and this is a great opportunity to get them involved. They can be your best resource at discovering why users are churning. Customer Support is the front-lines of the product, know your users best, and can provide some amazing insights.

Ask your Founders and Product Managers — what keeps them up at night?

This will open up some weak points in the business and could inspire solutions you could include in your cancellation flow design.

Design and craft the flow with care

Scope out the competition

Many successful companies are doing this well. Go ahead and attempt to cancel some services of your own and see what happens. Some are easy, some are more difficult. You’ll be surprised with what you uncover, what seems annoying or frivolous, or even irrelevant.

Map it out

Sketch out a wireframe of how users cancel accounts currently. This will help you identify where your current flow is lacking and what parts of it you can keep.

No need to get too fancy. A simple whiteboard session will do.
No need to get too fancy. A simple whiteboard session will do.

This is a particularly sensitive moment for your users, and designing it with empathy is important. Really put yourself in their shoes here and make cancellation easy to discover, and as painless as possible.

Netflix’s cancellation is easy to locate
Netflix’s cancellation is easy to locate

Some people believe that anything more than a big red cancelbutton is a dark pattern. I disagree — not everyone’s intention is to cancel. You convinced someone to pay for your service and they opened their wallets. They may want to cancel, but maybe they just want to talk to a human, or are frustrated and want to learn how to use your product properly. It’s your job to provide to them relevant information.

Make sure the exit ramp is clear

Always allow for an easy exit and don’t confuse people. If your cancellation flow is spread across multiple steps, you should always allow for a well-positioned cancel option on every page.

Remind users what they’ll be missing out on

Reiterate what they’ll be missing out on by unsubscribing. There’s a chance they’re not even sure what they’re paying for. This is definitely optional and not a must-have. Facebook takes it up a notch and uses some serious FOMO in their cancellation flow.

This is a bit aggressive, but it’s still good practice to remind the user what is it they’ll be missing. You can surface the number of friends they have, saved items, their ratings, savings, etc. If you’re dealing with confidential data, give them an option to download it or let them know that the data will be deleted by a certain date.

Leave a lasting impression

Once users have cancelled, leave them with a good feeling. With considered design and copy, this is easily achievable. If your service is compelling, many users will return.

One great example of this is Spotify — they keeps users loving the service even at the point of cancellation by sharing a fun Farewell playlist starting with I Want You Back by The Jackson 5.

Insurance startup Lemonade use an AI chatbot as part of a conversational cancellation flow. I’d be curious to see how adding this personal touch would test against a more traditional flow.

Use this as an opportunity to retain customers

You can use this stage in the flow to surface alternate deals or products. If you’re a subscription-based service, you could even offer the option to pause your subscription.

How awesome is Mailchimp’s surfacing of their alternative, simplified service tinyletter upon cancellation? 🔥🔥🔥

Amazon does a fantastic job at surfacing downgrade options while cancelling their Prime service. It also worked — I found that I was mostly using Prime Video but not really using their two-day shipping.

Both Hulu and Frank And Oak use a similar “Pause” or “Skip” function
Both Hulu and Frank And Oak use a similar “Pause” or “Skip” function

Rather than cancelling your subscription altogether, some companies offer the option to pause your subscription and push the renewal to the next month, or skip-a-month. You can use this pause data to reignite these customers.

How can Customer Support improve this experience?

While designing the entire flow, consider how your customer support team can help in this instance. Having customer support intervene in such a delicate situation can make frustrated users feel taken care of, and can have a massive impact on the number of people following through with cancellation.

Apps like Intercom or Messenger for Business can be integrated into your product site where appropriate, or you might consider linking to your global FAQ page, surfacing often asked questions.

Collect data with a survey

An optional survey is your last chance at collecting meaningful data. Survey forms can collect data and guide business decisions in the future, as well as help answer some key questions: Are you priced too high? Are users not finding value? Are there any competitors doing it better?

Mailchimp’s exit survey
Mailchimp’s exit survey

Even when a user has decided to disable their accounts or cancel their membership, they may consider you in the future. Many users bounce back and forth between apps before making a decision on which are important to them.

Account cancellation doesn’t always mean goodbye

It’s a great policy to keep the door open and make sure users know they’re always welcome back, no questions asked. Basecamp does this especially well, balancing casual and legal writing.

Basecamp’s cancellation confirmation email
Basecamp’s cancellation confirmation email

Sending a personalized confirmation email to remind users of cancellation and to re-iterate terms of cancellation will save your legal and support team a lot of time and resources. It’s also a great opportunity to say thank you one final time, and send one last email to the user. Hulu’s confirmation email highlights their top-watched shows while giving users a one-click opportunity to sign up again. Never give up on a customer.

Hulu’s confirmation email
Hulu’s confirmation email

Once you’ve implemented your cancellation flow, keep monitoring customer support and adjust it to cater to user needs moving forward.

Now you can focus on funneling new users in, maximizing the new user experience, and continuing to add value. 🚀

Want more? Here’s some additional reading…
How to Reduce Churn with a Customer-Focused Cancellation Flow
Good End of Customer Life Experiences with Mailchimp
Learning from Hulu’s Cancellation Flow
Making Sense of Customers Who Cancel
The NY Times Unsubscribe Dark Pattern
Two Ways to Reduce SaaS Cancellations
Audible’s Cancellation Flow
UX Best Practices for Cancellation Flows (Quora)— Frank